This post will contain my idea for the 4th Star Trek reboot movie. I know I am jumping the gun, the 3rd movie is still a year away, but what little has been released about the 3rd movie indicates it will take place in deep space. My idea takes place in federation space. If I were to be absolutely honest I think this idea should have been the 2nd movie in the reboot, but I liked Into Darkness (it kicked off my current obsession with Star Trek) so I will say no more.
In my opinion the 4th movie should take place on New Vulcan. The Enterprise is returning from their 5 year mission when they are ordered to stop by New Vulcan for memorials honoring the 7 year anniversary of the destruction of Vulcan. As the only federation ship to survive the confrontation, and the ship that saved the elders, the Enterprise has an honored role in the ceremonies. Unfortunately it quickly becomes evident that not all is well with New Vulcan.
I am going to backtrack a moment. In TOS episode 47 "The Immunity Syndrome" Spock feels the death of the crew of the Intrepid, a Federation Star Ship with an all Vulcan crew. If my memory serves me correctly, at one point during the episode Kirk asks Spock what the Vulcan's felt before they died, and Spock replies astonishment at being defeated. Vulcan's are a peaceful, but proud race. I don't know much about Vulcan history, but I got the impression that they were never the underdog. If they ever were they soon found a logical solution that brought them back to the top.
There was no warning and no logical reason for Vulcan to be destroyed (a Romulan from the future drunk on vengeance decided to destroy the Vulcan home world because a Vulcan ambassador failed to save the Romulan home world from a natural disaster in the future. Can you get any more convoluted?). If Vulcan's had never experienced a major defeat before they got hit with one to top all others with the destruction of their home world and consequently the decimation of their population. We are talking a population in the billions unexpectedly and in a short time being reduced to thousands. An event like that doesn't happen without effecting the cultures identity.
The Enterprise arrives at New Vulcan to discover a cultural battle being waged over the Vulcan's identity as a people. On one extreme you have the traditionalists who wish to carry on as if nothing had changed. On the other extreme you have Vulcan's who are questioning Surak's teachings. The first group is being led by some of the elders. The second group is being led by Spock's older brother Sybok, who embraced emotionalism before Vulcan was destroyed. Sybok survived the destruction of Vulcan because he and like minded Vulcan's were in voluntary exile.
The situation is further complicated by the younger Vulcan's (around Spock's age) being prone to emotional outburst following the destruction of their family links and the simultaneous death of billions of fellow Vulcans. Some if this group resorted to Kolinar (removing all emotion) to cope, others chose to follow Sybok. The remaining find themselves marked with the proverbial scarlet letter because of their emotional outbursts.
When the Enterprise's landing party arrives this third group rally around Spock as a Vulcan who has had emotional outbursts and yet follows Surak and holds an honored position as part of the crew that saved the elders. Spock is blindsided by this turn of events when he realizes that the same individuals that persecuted him as a child because of his human half are now honoring him for the same trait. He also realizes that part of the reason he was able to bounce back from the emotional outbursts was because he worked with a human crew. While human's expect emotional outbursts after extreme events they also expect a return to the norm once all is said and done. The Vulcan's turning to him are being treated like ticking time bombs.
There is fear that the situation will result in another split (the first being when the Romulan's split from the Vulcan's during Surak's time). This would be illogical in that it would divide the Vulcan's dwindling population. Additionally the destruction of Vulcan was caused by a Romulan, a species that resulted from the first split. This feared split causes one of the opposing groups (or a Kolinar adept who seeks to find the most logical response to the situation) to unleash some kind of technology to ensure that everyone gets along. Something that in the past would never have been considered. (I haven't been able to define what this is, but I vaguely conceive of it as similar to the Borg collective. Something that artificially heightens the telepathic links that bind the Vulcan race).
While all this is going on Spock is facing tangible proof of his own mortality when he visits the grave of his older self who died while the Enterprise was on it's 5 year mission. In addition Old Spock did as he told Young Spock he would and contributed to the re-population of Vulcan, leaving behind a child. On top of mourning his older self Spock has to figure out what his responsibility is toward this child, and at what level he wants to be part of his/her life. To further complicate personal matters, Spock is introduced to his new step mother, and brother/sister. As his father also did his duty in repopulating Vulcan.





